One night in Pinehurst
Matty P & Gibby
One Night in Pinehurst brings sports, music, and humor together in one lively weekly show. Hosts Matty P and Gibby tackle the NFL, NBA, MLB, golf, and more—joined by athletes, coaches, musicians, and America’s Best Friend, AB. Expect bold takes, big laughs, and the kind of conversations you’d have with friends after a round of golf.
Episodes
Episode 239: Week 5: Back in Business, Betting on Brissett
We're back after a week off, and while our DFS lineups haven't exactly been lighting the world on fire, we're convinced Week 5 is where things turn around. This week, we're going all in on the Detroit-Arizona matchup, stacking Jacoby Brissett with Michael Wilson and Trey McBride, and bringing it back with Jahmyr Gibbs. We also break down the value in Quinshon Judkins, Nico Collins, a potential breakout from Dante Myers, and why Deebo Samuel could be a difference-maker in a huge divisional matchup. Plus, we take an early look at the NBA season, debate the Celtics' future and the competition in the East, and recap a great weekend at Tee Off for 2E supporting Camp Sunshine. The picks have been cold, but the confidence hasn't gone anywhere. Let's get back on track. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 238: Back on the Horse
Week 3 is here, and we’re changing things up. We break down this week’s FanDuel lineup, including a Chargers-Bills stack, James Cook, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Dalton Kincaid, a contrarian Emmett Johnson play, and Carolina’s defense, while digging into matchups, game environments, and where the value is hiding. Plus, some early NFL Draft talk, Drew Lock nonsense, and a quick detour into the upcoming John Madden movie. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 237: Week 2 AB Gets the Credit Card
Week 2 is here, and AB is back after absolutely nailing David Montgomery last week. Naturally, we reward him by handing over the credit card and letting him spend big on Bijan Robinson. The crew builds out the rest of the DFS lineup, digs into the early-season defenses and offenses we’re already looking to attack, debates which Week 1 trends actually matter, and finds value across the slate. Plus: Broncos misery, Chargers schadenfreude, Tim Tebow, stadium complaints, anniversary love, and the usual collection of completely unnecessary detours. God bless and Go Broncos. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 236: We Are Assuredly Back
Football is officially back, and so are we. Maddie returns to break down the reaction to Drake Maye and the Patriots’ loss, why Seattle may be a nightmare matchup for New England, and what Drew Lock’s performance could mean for his future. Then we build our Week 1 FanDuel lineup, targeting Lions-Saints and Chargers-Cardinals, ride with Colston Loveland at tight end, and talk survivor strategy, betting angles, and teams that could surprise or completely bottom out this season. Plus, an early look at what could be an absolutely loaded 2027 NFL Draft class. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 235: How the media got the JB trade wrong
After a couple months away, Gibby, Matty, and Brandon are back, and there's only one place to start. We revisit the JB trade with the benefit of hindsight, break down where the media missed the mark, discuss the market that actually existed, and debate what Brad Stevens was really facing behind the scenes. Then, because we couldn't help ourselves, we wrap things up with some early NFL chatter—our biggest storylines heading into the season, AFC and NFC outlooks, why the Broncos and Patriots are two of the most intriguing teams in the league, and a few predictions before football officially kicks off. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 234: NFL Schedule Release
The NFL schedule is out and the boys are back. Matty P and Gibby break down the biggest takeaways from the 2026 NFL schedule release — from prime time overload and travel concerns to playoff sleepers, tanking candidates, and why the Jets might actually be… interesting? The guys dive into: Broncos and Patriots schedule reactions Why the Bengals and Cowboys could be dangerous The looming Arch Manning sweepstakes NFC East chaos and playoff predictions Fantasy implications of Thursday night football Which teams are quietly headed toward disaster Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 233: 2026 NFL Draft Preview Pt. 3 | RB Rankings + QB Takes
We wrap up our 2026 NFL Draft Preview with the positions everyone wants to talk about — running backs and quarterbacks. Which backs can make an instant fantasy impact? Who are the safest QB prospects? And which team could change its future with one pick? Brandon, Matty P and Gibby close out the preview with bold predictions, draft night scenarios, and the names that could define the first round. The finale is here. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 232: 2026 NFL Draft Preview Pt. 2 | Corners & WR Sleepers
It’s Part 2 of our 2026 NFL Draft Preview and we shift to the flashy positions. The boys break down corners, wide receivers, and the playmakers who could hear their names called early. Who’s a future WR1? Which corner can lock down on Sundays right away? And who might become the steal of the draft? Casten, Matty P and Gibby bring the takes, sleepers, and a few disagreements along the way. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 231: 2026 NFL Draft Preview Pt. 1 | Defense Wins Drafts w/ Casten
The boys are back with our 2026 NFL Draft Preview (Part 1) as we kick things off breaking down the defensive side of the ball. Which pass rushers can change a franchise immediately? Who are the safest bets in the secondary? And which prospects might be getting too much hype? Brandon, Matty P and Gibby talk impact defenders, draft fits, and the names you need to know before draft night. Defense wins championships… but does it win drafts? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 230- Crow’s Nest Dreams, Champion’s Dinner Debates & Masters Chaos
All things Masters—and it starts with one of the shots of the year. We break down Cameron Young’s absolute bomb on 18 at The Players and what it could mean for his breakout season, before diving headfirst into Augusta. In this episode: Who’s actually built to win at Augusta (and who might melt down) Why experience still trumps trends at the Masters Picks, long shots, and the guys flying under the radar The return of villains like Patrick Reed and why he might be a sneaky play A full breakdown of Rory’s Champions Dinner menu (and what we’d serve if we ever got the invite) The mystique of Augusta—from the Crow’s Nest to Butler Cabin Plus: dark horse bets, top 10 locks, and the guys most likely to be leading on Sunday… before it all falls apart. If you’re getting ready for Masters week, this is your preview—with a few laughs along the way. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 229- March Madness Preview w/ Mike Green
The boys are BACK for one of our favorite episodes of the year — the annual March Madness deep dive with returning guest (and bracket savant) Mike Green. We’re breaking down everything you need to know heading into the tournament: Why this year’s top tier might be historically dominant The KenPom + efficiency data that could shape your bracket Where the real upset value lives (hint: power conferences matter) Teams heating up at the right time (hello UCLA 👀) Why first-half unders might be the sharpest bet on the board The case for Michigan, Arizona, Illinois… and a few sneaky sleepers Plus: Cinderella candidates 🌵 Coaching storylines (Hurley chaos, Pitino magic, Cronin vibes) Final Four picks + futures strategy And of course… a little ONIP-style chaos along the way Whether you’re filling out a bracket, placing a bet, or just trying to sound smarter than your friends — this one’s for you. 🎯 Take the data. Trust the gut. And don’t forget… it’s March Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 228: Coach Hoy Returns — Celtics, Contenders & Draft Season
Coach Hoy is back and we’re diving headfirst into the NBA stretch run. We break down the Celtics’ playoff ceiling, Tatum’s return timeline, whether OKC or San Antonio should be the real favorites, and which under-the-radar teams could make noise. Plus: Giannis rumors, Brad Stevens masterclass cap talk, and an early look at a loaded NBA Draft class. Spring hoops energy is officially here. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 227: Super Bowl Week - Let's Get to Sunday
It’s Super Bowl week, and the noise is officially at full volume. We talk through what the week actually feels like — the overanalysis, the betting angles, Super Bowl squares, and that familiar stretch where optimism and skepticism live side by side. There’s some matchup talk, some fan therapy, and a lot of trying to figure out how we actually feel before kickoff. Nothing overproduced here. Just a real conversation about the build-up, the nerves, and getting to Sunday in one piece. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 226: Catching Up With Quinn Tuff of The Band Memo
Quinn Tuff of The Band Memo is back on the show, and it’s been a couple of years. We catch up on what he’s been up to with the band, talk music, life, and the weird experience of revisiting old recordings. There’s some reflection, some laughs, and the usual debate about whether Spotify is quietly hiding us from the world. We can't wait to see what is next for Quinn and The Band Memo Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 225: Low Stress Bets and Conference Championship weekend
Matt Captline from Low Stress Bets joins the show to talk discipline, playoff betting, and what it actually looks like to bet with a long-term mindset. The guys dig into what worked in 2025, where bettors tend to get themselves into trouble, and why alternate lines, weather, and knowing a division can matter more than chasing big payouts. There’s also a thoughtful conversation about treating betting more like investing — managing risk, staying patient, and letting small wins add up over time. They wrap with conference championship thoughts, Olympic hockey angles, and a few reminders about why “low stress” usually wins in the end. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 224: Championship Weekend + A Real QB Draft Exercise
Matty and Gibby are back after the break, diving straight into Championship Weekend and a big-picture quarterback conversation that’s been brewing all season. Who are you actually taking if you’re starting a franchise today? The guys build out a long-term QB ranking exercise — expansion draft style — breaking players into tiers, debating upside vs. availability, and separating narrative from reality. From Mahomes, Allen, Burrow, and Lamar at the top, to volatile risers like Caleb Williams, Bo Nix, Trevor Lawrence, and beyond, nothing is off limits. They also unpack playoff fallout, unsustainable wins, coaching context, turnover luck, and why “winning games” still matters more than highlight throws. Plus: Broncos pain, Bills frustration, Bears reality checks, Patriots optimism, and a look at how this QB era actually stacks up against past decades. We’re officially back — and this one felt good. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 224 – Ten Minutes: All You Need for Week 16
Quick pit stop for the Milly Boys. We didn’t want to disappear on you this week, so we’re dropping a fast, no-nonsense DFS and Week outlook to keep the streak alive. Lineup thoughts, game environments we’re targeting, incentives, pace spots, and just enough chaos to get you set—then go lock in with our full episode featuring Pigtown Sports. We’ll be back at full strength soon. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 223: Dominoes Fall & Landmines Ahead w/ Pigtown Sports
Episode 223 kicks off with a curveball as Gibby joins a little late—but the conversation is already humming when he arrives. The boys reunite with Alex and Zach for a wide-ranging, no-nonsense baseball discussion centered on one of the biggest questions of the offseason: who’s actually making the right moves—and who’s about to step on a landmine? The crew dives deep into the Orioles finally making a splash, what Pete Alonso’s signing really means, and whether Baltimore should prioritize pitching, lineup depth, or calculated trades. From Michael King and Ranger Suárez to Freddy Peralta trade hypotheticals, the guys break down which contracts will age well—and which ones absolutely won’t. Along the way, the conversation expands into: Why “rebuilding” doesn’t really exist in modern MLB How the Dodgers have warped everyone’s sense of roster construction The hidden danger of paying for names instead of production Why ownership groups crying poor don’t pass the smell test Gunnar Henderson’s trajectory and how real the Hall of Fame talk actually is Naturally, the episode closes with a detour into Ravens football, playoff stress, Lamar Jackson discourse, and the emotional toll of December sports. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 222: AB is back and we're due.
AB is back, the lineup is locked, and the boys are officially due. Gibby and Matty break down this week’s DFS slate with a simple goal: stop overthinking it and start cashing again. From paying up for Christian McCaffrey to trusting Puka, Jacoby Myers, and a few value plays that won’t send AB into a spiral, the crew walks through a lineup built for sanity and upside. They also hit Patriots–Bills playoff implications, AFC chaos, coaches on the hot seat, and why this offseason could get weird fast — plus a brief but necessary detour into the Philip Rivers conversation. Low ego, full transparency, and the belief that this is the week. We’re due. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 221: Week 13- Take a knee
It’s Week 13 on One Night in Pinehurst, and the boys are back for a slate so bad it should come with a warning label. Gibby and Matty break down a weekend of leftovers — the “cut down the tree” Sunday — where the only people watching all day are degenerates chasing parlays and FanDuel points. Between Gibby guiding his son away from Patriots fandom (into the warm wings of Eagles nation), a full-blown Trevor Lawrence burial, and a surprisingly deep dive into the state of NFL quarterbacking, this episode delivers everything from Madden revelations to future Super Bowl host city scouting. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 220: Trap Games, Costco Runs and Mac Jones in '26
The boys are back and firing up Week 12 with a full ONIP lineup build — starting with a Detroit Lions explosion spot. Gibbs, the Cousin, and Jameson Williams headline a week where Matty and Gibby are all in on the Lions getting right in the dome. From there, it’s a tour around the league: • Jacoby Brissette’s record-setting pace • Why this Arizona/Jacksonville matchup might quietly shoot out • The future of Kyler, Mac Jones, and the NFL’s looming QB chaos • Kamara bounce-back week • Kareem Hunt in a must-win for KC • Plus the obligatory Patriots/Bengals “is this a trap?” debate Gibby tells the story of Matty running into Rob Spillane at Costco, the guys reflect on awkward athlete encounters, and AB — cruising on back-to-back wins — becomes increasingly difficult to book. Your Week 12 FanDuel lineup: Brissette, Gibbs, Kamara, Jameson, Myers, Booty, McBride, Kareem Hunt, and the Raiders D. Another low-stress, high-vibes week under the ONIP umbrella. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 219: The wide open AFC
AB is back in the chair for Week 11, and the Milly Boys are feeling dangerous. Gibby, Matty P, and America’s Best Friend build out their FanDuel lineup, debate whether Lamar’s hamstring is worth worrying about, make the case for RJ Harvey as a volume play, and land on a cheap Atlanta defense ready to torment Bryce Young. There’s plenty of Broncos therapy, early-morning trolling, and a “team full of nicknames” as they talk through stacks, pivots, and how to stay sane when your finger gets itchy on late swap Sunday. Hit follow, lock in your lineup, and let ONIP ride with you into Week 11. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 218: Part II - College Football and FanDuel with KJ
Part I kicks off with a full-on college football deep dive as former Kennesaw State Owl KJ joins Matty P and Gibby to break down the rise of the Owls, the chaos in Conference USA, and why Ohio State looks untouchable this year. From NIL money and coaching carousels to sleeper bowl projections and next-gen quarterback prospects, the boys cover everything from the field to the film room—with plenty of laughs (and a few fantasy takes) along the way. Part II shifts gears to the NFL and FanDuel lineup build, where the crew debates breakout wide receivers, dream draft fits, and why trusting the Broncos might actually pay off. KJ sticks around to drop fantasy gems, roast a few play callers, and help the Milly Boys chase that elusive big-money lineup. 🏈 College. NFL. FanDuel. Chaos. Welcome to November football in Pinehurst. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 217: College Football Mid-Season Review with KJ
Part I kicks off with a full-on college football deep dive as former Kennesaw State Owl KJ joins Matty P and Gibby to break down the rise of the Owls, the chaos in Conference USA, and why Ohio State looks untouchable this year. From NIL money and coaching carousels to sleeper bowl projections and next-gen quarterback prospects, the boys cover everything from the field to the film room—with plenty of laughs (and a few fantasy takes) along the way. Part II shifts gears to the NFL and FanDuel lineup build, where the crew debates breakout wide receivers, dream draft fits, and why trusting the Broncos might actually pay off. KJ sticks around to drop fantasy gems, roast a few play callers, and help the Milly Boys chase that elusive big-money lineup. 🏈 College. NFL. FanDuel. Chaos. Welcome to November football in Pinehurst. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 216: Week 9 Lineup Build & The Midseason Madness
We’ve officially hit the halfway point of the NFL season — and Matty P and Gibby are in midseason form. This week, the boys break down a packed slate featuring Bills-Chiefs at 4:25, Denver’s sneaky playoff chances, and whether the Patriots are on a collision course with destiny (or disaster). They dig into lineup strategy with a few familiar names and some new faces: 🏈 Rashee Rice as the new Kelsey 💪 James Cook’s must-start moment 🧊 Jordan Love finding rhythm in Green Bay 🔥 Loveland, DK Metcalf, and the under-the-radar guys who can make or break your Sunday Plus: an in-episode ad debut, a low-stress-bet heartbreak, EMF conspiracy theories about the 49ers, and a few trademark Pinehurst tangents that somehow tie it all together. 🎧 Listen in for the laughs, the lineup locks, and a little perspective on football, friendship, and keeping your stress low when your team’s on the brink. #ONIP #OneNightInPinehurst #NFLWeek9 #FantasyFootball #FanDuel #SportsPodcast #Patriots #Broncos #Bills #Chiefs Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 215: Week 8: “AB, MP & Gibby’s Magic Episode”
The boys are back — winners of four of their last seven FanDuel contests — and feeling (just barely) in the black for the season. In classic One Night in Pinehurst fashion, Gibby, Matty P, and America’s Best Friend (AB) dive into a mix of lineup logic, football therapy, and completely off-the-rails tangents that somehow circle back to fantasy value. They kick things off with “Love on Time” by Quinn Tuff and the band Memo before spiraling into everything from Vegas’ offensive meltdown to the ongoing saga of Broncos heartbreak and redemption. Gibby waxes poetic about Drake May’s heater, Matty P mourns the state of Carson Wentz, and AB continues his Costanza streak of fantasy heartbreak — all while crafting a Week 8 lineup built on both conviction and chaos. This episode’s lineup features Drake May, Rashad White, Rico Dowdell, Stefon Diggs, Cortland Sutton, Jamar Chase, Kyle Pitts, Tyler Allgeier, and the Atlanta defense — a build Matty swears “feels like six-figure potential.” Along the way, the guys debate Vegas nightlife, Kmart’s mysterious survival, and whether Mike McDaniel might one day join a Spanish cartel. It’s a perfect blend of sports talk, sideways humor, and insider fantasy strategy — the signature One Night in Pinehurst balance of logic and lunacy. Tune in for: Why Drake May’s QB play is “unsustainably elite” Why you should never trust a Costanza streak The return of Gibby’s Broncos emotional support texts “Find the Kmart, find the value” — a new Pinehurst mantra 🎧 One Night in Pinehurst: Where the bets are low-stress, the banter’s high-energy, and every week feels like a win (even when it’s not). Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 214: Week 8: Facing Fears and Feeding the Studs
Matty P and Gibby are back, breaking down Week 8 of the NFL season with the signature ONIP blend of humor, strategy, and mild disbelief at how bad the international games are. From Canada-based FanDuel bets to fantasy lineup pivots, the boys hit it all — dissecting why Mahomes remains a top fantasy play, why Judkins could feast against Miami, and how Lad McConkey might finally reward AB’s trust issues. They talk matchups (start anyone vs. Cincy, Dallas, or Miami), breakout candidates, and the weirdly deep philosophies behind Sean Payton’s play-calling and the AFC’s parity problem. Along the way: French football announcers, Taysom Hill rants, and a reminder that Cleveland’s defense might be the only thing standing between chaos and clarity. 🎧 Tune in for smart FanDuel lineup talk, bad travel takes, and a dose of midseason football therapy — only on One Night in Pinehurst. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 213: Low-Stress Bets: Beating the Market
Matty P and Gibby welcome Matt Captline, founder of Low Stress Bets, to talk about how his disciplined, data-driven approach to sports betting has outperformed the S&P 500 in seven of the last twelve months. They dive into the art of “low stress” betting — avoiding parlays, stacking small wins, and applying investment logic to sports wagers. From Steelers futures to live PGA picks, Matt explains how patience and process can turn betting into a long-term strategy, not a gamble. The crew also swaps thoughts on Warren Buffett, golf course management, and gas station snacks — all wrapped in classic One Night in Pinehurst banter. 🎯 Follow Matt at LowStressBets.com and on Instagram & YouTube for his latest plays. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 212: One Night in Pinehurst – Week 6: Chuba Purdy and the Smart Lineup
The Milly Boys are back and searching for that elusive big cash. Gibby, Matty P, and AB break down a fresh FanDuel lineup after last week’s near miss — including a “get-right” pick from AB that’s got the crew all-in on Josh Jacobs. They debate whether to trust Rhamondre Stevenson, laugh through Brock Purdy family tree conspiracies (yes, Chuba Purdy is real), and drop a few gems on which defenses and receivers are officially in “start everyone against them” territory. There’s also a quick victory lap for the Tee Off for 2E hats (shoutout Chase & Sons), a cameo of chaos from AB’s research spiral, and a tease for next week’s guest, Matt from Low Stress Bets, who joins to talk about treating DFS like an investment. It’s a smart lineup, a cash week, and another classic ONIP blend of football analysis and sideways laughter. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 211: Week 5 Lineup Build & Tee Off for 2E
Gibby, Matty P, and AB put together their Week 5 FanDuel Milly lineup, debating risky plays, chalk locks, and sneaky stacks that could win big. Along the way, they roast Boomer’s bad nicknames, sneak in a Broncos reference, and celebrate the 14th annual Tee Off for 2E — on track to raise $100K for Camp Sunshine. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 210: Week 4- No Waiver Broncos for You
The Milly Boys are back for Week 4 — with AB’s long-awaited return to the lineup and plenty of sins to wash away from the rough first three weeks. Gibby, Matty P, and AB dive into the DFS slate, debating TreVeyon Henderson’s fumbling-free upside, James Cook’s hip fluidity, and why Roma Dunze might just be the most consistent receiver you’re not playing enough. Along the way, the guys tackle Caleb’s surprising fantasy consistency, Puka’s early case for receiver of the year, and the heartbreak of a local Chili’s closing its doors. With laughs about pillow forts, Emo Rick the lawyer, and the rule that should exist (“No Waiver Broncos for You”), the boys still manage to cash — turning $15 into $25. It may not be triple-digit winnings, but it’s momentum heading into the next week’s magic. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 209: Week 3 Magic Lineup
Matty P and Gibby are back with one of their sharpest FanDuel builds yet — and this one feels like it’s got true Milly Maker upside. The guys open with a heartfelt nod to the upcoming Tee Off for 2E charity event, celebrating 14 years of supporting Camp Sunshine and passing the $100K milestone. From there, it’s all about Week 3. They break down why Caleb Williams and Rome Odunze are a sneaky stack against Dallas, debate whether CeeDee is still worth the chalk, and talk up overlooked targets like Jacobi Meyers and Wondell Robinson. Running backs get their due with Bijan Robinson, Jonathan Taylor, and Kenneth Walker highlighted as the volume plays that separate good lineups from great ones. Along the way, you’ll hear takes on Jameis Winston trade rumors, frustrations with the “tush push,” the art of spotting low-owned gems, and why Atlanta’s defense might be the sneakiest play on the slate. Projected at 120+ points but with real 175–200 potential, this lineup is built for fireworks. As Matty puts it — if six guys go off and the rest hold steady, we’re in the money. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 208: Overreacting to Week 1
Gibby and MP are back to break down a wild Week Two in the NFL — from quarterbacks surprising (and disappointing) to teams already showing their true colors. The guys hit on everything from Dak Prescott to Christian McCaffrey, vent a little about some head-scratching plays (and even more questionable fan behavior), and, of course, build out their fantasy lineup for the week ahead. Plenty of laughs, a little frustration, and a few bold predictions you won’t want to miss. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 207- A Triumphant Return: The Milly Boys are Back
Football is back, and so are the Milly Boys! Gibby and Matty P welcome AB back to the show as the crew builds their Week 1 FanDuel Millionaire Maker lineup. From AB’s ride-or-die loyalty to Christian McCaffrey, to Gibby’s gut calls, to Matty’s data-driven breakdowns, the guys lock in their picks and debate the best value plays on the slate. This week’s lineup features a mix of proven stars and underpriced breakouts, including Drake Maye, McCaffrey, Jamar Chase, Drake London, and more. Along the way, they dive into Patriots optimism, FanDuel frustrations, and why you should never underestimate Denver’s defense. Whether you’re chasing the million yourself or just here for the laughs, it’s the perfect kickoff to another NFL season with the Millie Boys. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 206: Deep Dive into NFL Over/Under Win Totals with Insights from Eric Pocock
Continuing the conversation, Matty P, Gibby, and Eric Pocock offer a deep dive into NFL over/under win totals, providing predictions and expert analysis. This episode covers a range of teams and scenarios, offering listeners engaging and informative content that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Don't miss out on this comprehensive look at the upcoming NFL season. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 205: NFL Over/Under Win Totals- The North and West
In this episode, hosts Matty P and Gibby, joined by West Coast correspondent Eric Pocock, dive into the NFL over/under win totals, focusing on the Broncos and the competitive AFC West. They explore key factors, potential surprises, and offer insights into which teams might exceed expectations. Whether you're a seasoned fan or new to the game, this episode is packed with valuable insights to enhance your understanding of the NFL landscape. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 204: NFL Playoff Team Swap- with Brandon Casten
Matty P and Gibby, joined live in studio by Brandon Casten put a twist on the NFL postseason by taking each playoff team and swapping playoff teams from 2024 with who will rise to the top in 2025. We talk vibes, injuries, schedules and are prepared to look like idiots in 4 months. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 203: The Impact of Hulk Hogan with Pat Casten
This week, we’re joined by longtime friend and wrestling aficionado Pat Casten to reflect on the complex legacy of the recently passed icon, Hulk Hogan. We dive deep into what made Hogan larger than life, where he fits in wrestling history, and how nostalgia and controversy collide when icons fall. Then it’s time for our Mount Rushmore of WWE superstars — expect bold picks, fierce debate, and a little love for tag teams of old. And finally, we somehow land on what Jim Harbaugh and Justin Herbert have in common with The Rock & Roll Express… yeah, it goes there. Lace up your boots — this one’s got range. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 202: Pigtown Sports and Bastow
Former big leaguer Zach Moore of Pigtown Sports joins the show as Matty and Gibby attempt to talk Orioles fans off the ledge after a rough stretch in Birdland. We cover what’s real, what’s fixable, and why this team still has the tools to contend. Zach also takes us inside one of baseball’s most surreal moments: the MLB Draft phone call — and what it felt like to go from a kid with a dream to a Major League ballplayer. Baltimore correspondent Alex Bastow returns with some much-needed perspective, a few jabs, and a hint of cautious optimism. 🎧 Tap in now — link in bio. #Orioles #PigtownSports #MLBDraft #Birdland #OneNightInPinehurst #BaseballPodcast #ONIP Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 201: Taylor Rae
On this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, we’re joined by the genre-bending, soul-stirring Taylor Rae — fresh off the release of her latest album The Void. Calling in from Austin ahead of her show in Cambridge, Taylor talks with us about life on the road, the evolution of her sound, and what went into making her second record. We dive into songwriting, staying grounded in a fast-moving industry, and why elevation really does make your lips dry. Whether you're new to her music or a longtime fan, this one is pure gold. 🎶 The Void is out now — stream it everywhere you listen to music. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 200 – “Still a Thoroughbred”
The boys are back, and it feels real good. After a brief hiatus, Matty and Gibby return to the mic to celebrate 200 episodes of One Night in Pinehurst. It’s part self-congratulations, part therapy, part reunion — and fully ONIP. They reflect on what kept them away, why this podcast still gallops like a thoroughbred, and why Shohei Ohtani’s return mirrors their own. Cheers to 200 and the ride ahead. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 199- NFL Draft Recap with KJ Hancock
The mock drafts are in the trash — it’s time for the real thing. On this episode of One Night in Pinehurst, Matty P and Gibby welcome back recurring guest and college football insider KJ Hancock, who gives us a front-row seat to draft day emotions as his brother, Jordan Hancock, gets selected by the Buffalo Bills. We talk Patriots optimism, front office chaos, new grading systems, and what it really feels like when your family hears that name called. 🎙️🏈 Tap in now — link in bio! #NFLDraft #DraftRecap #OneNightInPinehurst #JordanHancock #BuffaloBills #FootballPodcast #SportsTalk #MattyP #Gibby #GridironStories #DraftDayFeels #PinehurstVibes #KJHancock Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 198: The Draft Room is Open — NFL Draft Preview with Casten
🚨 NFL Draft Season is Here 🚨 The One Night in Pinehurst war room is live and fully loaded for a complete 2025 NFL Draft Preview. Matty P and Gibby are joined by the always insightful Brandon Casten to talk fits, surprises, sleepers, and what your team should do (but probably won’t). From top-10 trades to late-round gems, the crew dives deep into every angle of the draft board. No gimmicks. Just vibes, mics, and 32 franchises about to change their future. 🎙️ Tap in for bold predictions, hot takes, and Pinehurst-approved analysis. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 197: Playoff Mode Activated: Coach Hoy’s NBA Postseason Preview
The playoffs snuck up on Matty P, but that won’t stop the ONIP crew from diving deep into the NBA postseason. Gibby and Matty P are joined by the one and only Coach Hoy to preview every angle of the 2025 NBA Playoffs — from whether the Celtics should be feared to the most chaotic matchups out West. They talk first-round fears, surprise x-factors, pressure-packed coaching situations, and who’s got that real postseason dawg in them. It’s smart hoops talk with classic ONIP flavor — thoughtful, unpredictable, and always entertaining. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 196: Masters Preview with Bud Copeland
It’s the best week of the year—Masters Week—and One Night in Pinehurst is going full azalea mode. Matty P and Gibby are joined by our favorite golf expert and cohost of Fairways & Dreams, Bud Copeland, for a deep dive into everything Augusta. We’re talking course changes, favorite traditions, the players to watch (and fade), and why this year’s tournament could be one for the books. Bud brings the insight, the vibes, and maybe a few surprises from Magnolia Lane. Grab your pimento cheese and settle in—this is your official 2025 Masters preview. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 195: Part 2! NCAA March Madness Preview with Mike Green
Matty P and Gibby are joined by college basketball expert Mike Green for a definitive 2-part March Madness preview! We’re diving deep into Vegas lines, uncovering upset specials, and breaking down key storylines to follow. Plus, we tackle the KEMPOM method to identify teams primed for a deep run and discuss the wild rumor of Belichick recruiting at halftime of the UNC game. Whether you’re filling out your bracket or hunting for value in the betting market, this is the ultimate March Madness preview you can’t miss! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 194: NCAA March Madness Preview with Mike Green- Part 1
Matty P and Gibby are joined by college basketball expert Mike Green for a definitive 2-part March Madness preview! We’re diving deep into Vegas lines, uncovering upset specials, and breaking down key storylines to follow. Plus, we tackle the KEMPOM method to identify teams primed for a deep run and discuss the wild rumor of Belichick recruiting at halftime of the UNC game. Whether you’re filling out your bracket or hunting for value in the betting market, this is the ultimate March Madness preview you can’t miss! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 193: NFL Free Agency Recap – Winners, Losers & Question Marks
The first wave of NFL free agency is in the books, and we’re breaking it all down! Who were the biggest losers of the offseason? Can Denver hang another banner, or are they just hanging on? And did the Patriots actually get value out of their moves, or are they just treading water? Matty P and Gibby tackle all the big questions, plus some underrated signings and the most head-scratching deals. Tune in for the full breakdown! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 192: Spring Training Preview – Part 2 with Alex Bastow and Ryan Ripken
The conversation continues as One Night in Pinehurst welcomes back Ryan Ripken for Part 2 of our MLB Spring Training Preview. Ryan dives deeper into his baseball experiences, reflecting on the legendary players he’s crossed paths with and the lasting impact of the game beyond the stat sheet. Matty P and Gibby get into the latest storylines, including key player developments, Baltimore’s pitching outlook, and the mental side of the sport. Plus, Ryan shares behind-the-scenes stories from his time in AAA, his relationships with current MLB stars, and what excites him most about the upcoming season. It’s another can’t-miss baseball discussion filled with insights, laughs, and plenty of Orioles talk. Tune in now and get ready for Opening Day! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episode 191: Part 1- Spring Training Preview – Featuring Ryan Ripken & Alex Bastow
Spring is in the air, and that means baseball is back! Matty P and Gibby are joined by two special guests—Ryan Ripken, host of The Ryan Ripken Show, and Alex Bastow, our resident Baltimore Orioles superfan. The crew dives into all things MLB, from early season storylines to what’s brewing in Baltimore. Ryan shares insights from his time with Bills Mafia and reflects on his whirlwind travels, while Alex gives us the latest scoop on the O’s. Plus, Matty takes the reins as we break down key teams, players to watch, and some bold predictions heading into the season. Whether you're a die-hard baseball fan or just getting into the swing of things, this episode has something for everyone. Grab your peanuts and Cracker Jacks—it's time for One Night in Pinehurst! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices