The Crawfordsville Peach Cast
Dave Peach
Join Dave Peach and Dave Meyer as they discuss movies ranging from the obscure to the most ridiculous. Plus, catch special guests from local heroes to sporting legends; all straight from the Athens of Indiana. Who knows what’s in store from these two!
Episodes
#238 Untoasted: Girls! Girls! Girls! (1962)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1962 musical Girls! Girls! Girls! starring Elvis Presley and Stella Stevens. They also talk about being a red-blooded man; Hallmark movies; and the death of the King.
#237: Mixed Bag Vol. 33
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including trouble with customer service; Paul Simon; and old movie trivia.
#236 Untoasted: Million Dollar Baby (2004)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 2004 sports drama 'Million Dollar Baby' starring Hilary Swank and Clint Eastwood. They also talk about depressing movies, boxing, and Indiana food.
#235 Untoasted: Evel Knievel (1971)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1971 biographical film "Evel Knievel". They also talk about Meyer's cold; the lost infomercial starring George Hamilton; and Cheap Seats.
#234: Mixed Bag Vol. 32
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including more Jeopardy! answers; boxers vs. briefs; and poutine.
#233 Untoasted: State and Main (2000)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 2000 rom-com State and Main starring William H. Macy and Sarah Jessica Parker.
#232 Untoasted: The Rocketeer (1991)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1991 sci-fi film "The Rocketeer" starring Billy Campbell and Jennifer Connelly. They also talk about the 1975 World Series, Iron Man, and classic Hollywood.
#231: Mixed Bag Vol. 31
Peach and Meyer discuss the top 52 yacht rock songs (as chosen by Peach), the Savannah Bananas, and the Late-Night Wars.
SPECIAL: NFL 2026 ft. Jeff Nelson
Peach and Jeff Nelson discuss what's to come in the 2026 NFL season.
#229 Untoasted: Streets of Fire (1984)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1984 crime movie "Streets of Fire" starring Michael Paré and Diane Lane. They also talk about the Mandela Effect, the "Dead Dans", and sleeping on the couch.
#228: The Long Riders (1980)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1980 film "The Long Riders" starring David Carradine and James Keach. They also talk about jellyfish, "women of extremely high character", and the life of a bank robber. Check out the video episode on YouTube: Crawfordsville Radio Network (CRN) - YouTube
#227: Mixed Bag Vol. 30
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including gold, survival food, and Peach's flying adventures.
#226 Untoasted: Find Me Guilty (2006)
Peach and Meyer discuss the courtroom comedy "Find Me Guilty" starring Mark Sinclair and Alex Rocco. They also talk about Vin Diesel's real name, back-to-school shopping, and Rudy Giuliani.
#225: 2026 Colts Season ft. Matt Taylor
Matt Taylor, who serves as the radio voice for the Indianapolis Colts, joined the Peach Cast to talk football as the 2026 NFL season poises to kick off.
#224: Mixed Bag Vol. 29
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including The Crawfordsville Strawberry Festival, Eyes on the Stars, and Glengarry Glen Ross.
#223: Mixed Bag Vol. 28
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including uncomfortable shoes, shrinkflation, and Dick van Dyke.
#222 Untoasted: 1776 (1972)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1972 historical film "1776" starring William Daniels and Howard da Silva.
SPECIAL: Ronald Nored
Peach and Meyer talk Butler basketball with the head coach himself, Ronald Nored.
#221 Untoasted: Tiptoes (2002)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 2002 comedy/drama "Tiptoes" starring Matthew McConaughey and Gary Oldman. They also talk about a new highlighter; film festivals; and being kissed in the mouth by a stranger.
#220: Mixed Bag Vol. 27
Peach, Meyer, and Dean Jones discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including Jamie Ding, lost pens, and a trip to Disney World.
#219 Untoasted: Almost Famous (2000)
Peach, Meyer, and Dean Jones discuss the 2000 film "Almost Famous" starring Billy Crudup and Frances McDormand.
#218: Superfan Chronicles Vol. 1
Peach and Meyer are joined by superfan Dean Jones to talk about the 2026 Indy 500, movies, and Wilbur Snyder.
#217: Mixed Bag Vol. 26
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including the champaign of happiness, The Oldest Rookie, and magma.
#216 Untoasted: The Man Who Loved Cat Dancing (1973)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1973 Western film The Man Who Loved Cat Dancing starring Burt Reynolds and Sarah Miles.
#215: Mixed Bag Vol. 25
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including the three definitive Hall & Oates songs; one-off artists; and Abba.
#214 Untoasted: Fast Break (1979)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1979 film Fast Break starring Gabe Kaplan and Harold Sylvester. They also talk about Whatchamacallit bars, and the greatest trivia question for people their age.
#213: Mixed Bag Vol. 24
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including the most favored days of the week; The Masked Singer predictions; and Meyer's trip to Milan, Italy.
#212 Untoasted: The Last Picture Show (1971)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1971 film The Last Picture Show starring Timothy Bottoms and Jeff Bridges. They also talk about Cowboy Bob; cats eating plants; and "that TV show with the kids who go to that place".
#211 Untoasted: Living in Oblivion (1995)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1995 black comedy "Living in Oblivion" starring Steve Buscemi and Catherine Keener. They also talk about GreatClips, The Pogues, and the making of films.
#210 Untoasted: Tin Cup (1996)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1996 rom-com drama "Tin Cup" starring Kevin Costner and Rene Russo. They also talk about armadillos, love triangles, and evading the IRS.
#209 Untoasted: Miller's Crossing (1990)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1990 noir-film Miller's Crossing, which stars Gabriel Byrne and Marcia Gay Harden. They also discuss the Coen Brothers, the Godfather, and mob wars.
#208 Untoasted: An Innocent Man (1989)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1989 thriller "An Innocent Man" starring Tom Selleck and Larry Brothers. They also talk about getting NBC tattooed on your chest; deciding between chicken and drugs; and "taking care" of old friends.
#207 Untoasted: Runaway Train (1985)
Peach and Meyer discuss the action-thriller movie (not the song) Runaway Train, which stars Jon Voight and Eric Roberts. They also talk about doing evil well; escaping prison using pig fat; and Tarleton State.
SPECIAL: Brandon Gaudin Returns
Brandon Gaudin joins the Peach Cast again! He'll be joined alongside seven other announcers on CBS for March Madness this year. He's also the voice of the Atlanta Braves and can be heard as an announcer on the Madden video game franchise.
#206 Untoasted: Extreme Prejudice (1987)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1987 western Extreme Prejudice starring Nick Nolte and Powers Boothe. They also talk about the action rom-com genre; the Mount Rushmore of People Named Rip; and going out in a blaze of glory.
#205: Mixed Bag Vol. 23
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including Sunday morning television; saying goodnight to the Pro Bowl; the Butler rant; and Bill Belichick.
#204: Mixed Bag Vol. 22
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including Peach's apology to an old friend, naming a song, and the NCAA point shaving scandal.
#203 Untoasted: Pirate Radio (2009)
Peach and Meyer review the comedy "Pirate Radio" starring Philip Seymour Hoffman and Bill Nighy. They also talk about the greatest story in human history; taking on the British government; and the spirit of radio.
#202: Mixed Bag Vol. 21
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including buying shoes at Costco, the January 3rd Incident, and the epitome of word pronunciations.
#201 Untoasted: True Grit (2010)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 2010 adaptation of True Grit starring Jeff Bridges and Hailee Steinfeld. They also talk about doing crunches, being out on the prairie, and not being able to snuff the Rooster.
#200 Untoasted: Another Simple Favor (2025)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 2025 film "Another Simple Favor" starring Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively. They also talk about the Rob Lowe headphone thing, shower drinking, and unexpected twins.
#199: Mixed Bag Vol. 20
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary including proper chip etiquette, responses to spam texts, and Butler basketball.
#198 Untoasted: Rollerball (1975)
Peach and Meyer discuss the 1975 film "Rollerball" starring James Caan and John Houseman. They also talk about dystopian movies, corporate wars, and napalming trees.
#197: NFL Playoffs (2026)
Jeff Nelson returns to the mic to talk football as the NFL playoffs get underway.
#196: Season 5 Movie Selection
Happy 2026! With a new year comes new movies, and Peach and Meyer have their picks for Season 5!
#195: Trivia Games
Peach and Meyer challenge themselves in a series of trivia and board games.
#194: Mixed Bag Vol. 19
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including a new word, the 1980 Grammys, and doing NFL promos in the woods.
#193: Mixed Bag Vol. 18
Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including saving the universe with the Ninja Kidz, baseball with British royalty, and not hanging up the phone.
#192 Untoasted: Mr. Right (2015)
On the Season 4 finale of Untoasted, Peach and Meyer discuss the 2015 film Mr. Right starring Sam Rockwell and Anna Kendrick. They also talk about a Butler family reunion, a set-up, and living a double life as an assassin.
#191: Mixed Bag Vol. 17
On this special Thanksgiving edition, Peach and Meyer discuss topics from the ordinary to the extraordinary, including taking a pop quiz, curds in the third, and the new segment: "Dave and his Uber Drivers".