Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia
Hailey and Holly
Welcome to Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia, a true crime podcast hosted by Holly and Hailey. Join us each week as we dive into murders, missing persons cases, and other spooky and paranormal happenings in the mountains of Appalachia.
Episodes
The Lillelid Family Take 2
Join us this month for our 6th anniversary! We are bringing back our very first episode. Support the show
The First Electric Chair Execution
Join us this week as we discuss the case of the first individual executed by the electric chair. Support the show
The History of the Death Penalty Part 2
Join us for Part 2!Support the show
The History of the Death Penalty Part 1
Join us this month as we discuss the morbid history of the Death Penalty in the United States. Support the show
Colonial Punishments
We're back!!! Its been a rough couple of months for us but we are back and bringing you a new episode. This month we talk about punishments used in colonial times. Support the show
The Giggling Granny Part 2
Join us this week for the conclusion of the Giggling Granny case. Support the show
The Giggling Granny Part 1
Join us this month for the case of the giggling Granny. Is she a sweet old lady that has experienced so much tragedy or a cold blooded killer?Support the show
Twelve Tribes Pt. 2
Join us for part 2 of our discussion on the twelve tribes. Support the show
Twelve Tribes Pt. 1
Join us this week as we talk about a group operating in Appalachia, specifically along the Appalachian trail. Are they a cult or just a friendly group of like minded people? Support the show
Mamie Thurman Pt. 2
Part 2 of the Maimee Thurman case! Support the show
Mamie Thurman Pt. 1
Y'all this episode may be cursed! We lost the original audio, rerecorded on zoom, and Hailey's computer almost bit the dust. This is one of the most interesting cases we have covered in a while so thanks for bearing with us! Support the show
Anjette Lyles
This month we discuss female serial killer Anjette Lyles. Whatever you do, don't let her make you a drink. Support the show
The Brinkley College Ghost
Join us for this months episode about Brinkley College. We discuss its history and its hauntings! Support the show
ANNOUNCEMENT!!!!!
AHHHHH!!!!! We are taking a leap! Listen in to hear about our new project! Support the show
The Lizard Man
Happy 5 year anniversary to us!!! Thank you all for joining us for this weeks episode as we talk about the legend of the Lizard man. Support the show
Mary Shotwell Little Part 2
Join us for the final part of the Mary Shotwell Little story.Support the show
Mary Shotwell Little Part 1
This week we dive into the disappearance of Mary Shotwell Little.Support the show
The Signal Mountain Murders
Join us this week as we discuss a triple homicide out of Tennessee. Support the show
Baby in the Closet
Join us as we discuss a developing case out of Kentucky. Support the show
The Case of LaLurie
Join us this week for another case from Hailey's travels to New Orleans. We discuss the horrific case of LaLurie. Support the show
The Alford Plea
Join us this week as we talk about the case that brought about the Alford Plea. Support the show
Jazz it Out
Join us this week as we take it to New Orleans to discuss the axeman murders in the early 1900s.Support the show
Kidnapped from a Fire
Join us this week for a new episode! Support the show
The Ogua River Monster
Join us this week as we discuss a cryptid from the great state of West Virginia! Support the show
What Happened to the Children
Join us this week for a new mystery!Support the show
Jereboam Beauchamp Part 2
Join us this week for part 2 of last weeks episode! Support the show
Jereboam Beauchamp Part 1
Join us this week for a twisted tale out of Kentucky. There is so much going on in this one we made it two parts! Support the show
The Greenpark Inn
Join us this week as we discuss the history of the Greenpark Inn. Support the show
A 1933 Murder
Join us this week as we take it back to 1933 to discuss a mysterious murder. This one is a true whodunit? Support the show
Murdered for Having a Girl
Join us this week as we discuss the case of Samantha Garnier. Support the show
Ann Gutlib
This week we discuss the case of Ann Gutlib. A young girl who went missing on her first day of summer vacation in Louisville Kentucky. Support the show
Brandy Canipe
Join us this week as we discuss the case of Brandy Canipe. Brandy vanished in 2006 from her hometown in North Carolina. Her sister has been using TikTok to help share Brandy's story. Support the show
The Lost Colony
Join us this week as we discuss one of the oldest mysteries in US history!Support the show
Americas First Mass Murder
Join us this week as we discuss the first mass murder in the United States. Support the show
The Olde Pink House
Join us this week as we travel to Savannah Georgia. We discuss the history and ghosts of the Olde Pink House. Support the show
A Body in the Basement
Join us this week as we discuss a case out of NYC. A body is found in a basement cased in concrete. Listen to find out who she was and how she was finally identified. Support the show
Serial Killer Henry Wallace
Join us this week as we discuss the "Taco Bell Strangler". Support the show
House of Horror
Join us this week as we discuss a recent case from Connecticut. Support the show
The Read Hotel
Join us this week as we discuss the Read Hotel in Tennessee and its many haunting. Support the show
A Circus Train Wreck
It was 1915 when a train full of circus performers were heading out to an upcoming show. Sadly, many lost their lives after a head-on collision with another train. It’s said those lost are still trying to make the show and their ghostly figures can still be seen! Join us for this exciting episode!Support the show
The UFO Boom of 1973
This week we discuss the UFO Boom of 1973 in Tennessee. We even hop down to Mississippi to discuss an abduction! Support the show
A Murderer's Baptism
Join us this week as we discuss a brutal murder and a sensationalized baptism. Support the show
The Ballad of Tom Dooley
Join us this week as we discuss the ballad of Tom Dooley. Its a great tune but a tragic tale. Support the show
The Watcher House
We pulled one out of the patreon vault this week! With gross weather and sickness abound we wanted to make sure you guys had an episode even if we could not record together. Wash your hands folks and we will see you next week! Support the show
The Manure Crisis of 1894
The title says it all... join us for a fun one this week! Support the show
Bobby Mackeys Music House
Join us this week as we discuss the troubled and haunted history of Bobby Mackeys Music House. Support the show
Terry Hyatt
When a drunken man stumbles into a North Carolina police station with tales of murder, the staff are cautious yet intrigued. Are these merely ramblings of an incoherent man or a confession?Support the show
Bodies in the Pond
Charles and Catherine had it all... money, homes, and a life of luxury. Their good fortune seemingly came to an end when they went missing from their Georgia hotel. Support the show
The Monongah Mine Disaster
Join us this week as we travel to West Virginia to discuss the Monongah Mine Disaster. This tragedy created many new departments but did it create change? Support the show
Case Updates
Join us this week for case updates on two cases we have covered. Support the show